17
Sep
2007
Posted by Ben Cook as Blog Marketing

If you checked out any blogs in the make money online or blogging about blogging niche, chances are you’ve already heard plenty about BlogRush. For the rest of you, according to their website:
“BlogRush is a free service that was created to help bloggers solve their #1 need:
More Readers For Their Blog.By adding the BlogRush Widget to a blog, a blogger can get instant distribution for their latest blog post titles across a network of related blogs.
BlogRush users earn “syndication credits” (the right to have their blog post titles shown inside a widget on another related blog) based on their own traffic (loads of the widget) as well as the traffic of other users they refer to BlogRush. Users can automatically refer others to BlogRush via special links on the widget, as well as through the promotion of a special referral URL they are given.”
More traffic for free? Sounds great right? As if that weren’t enough, John Chow states that BlogRush was “designed to be incredibly viral and to provide its users with tremendous distribution leverage to receive exposure for their blog content that they could never achieve on their own.” Darren Rowse and Yaro Starak’s reviews were slightly more reserved but still suggests giving it a go. So with positive reviews from some of the top authorities in my niche you’d probably expect me to write up a glowing review of this new service to try and wrack up the referrals right? Wrong.
Sign Up But…
While I think BlogRush could certainly be a worthwhile service for you to sign up for, I’d urge you to be very careful about HOW you sign up. In my opinion, BlogRush’s 10 tier affiliate program, which is being tauted as one of the biggest reasons you should sign up, is in fact the programs biggest weakness. Darren’s post included this explanation of the affiliate system:
Not only that - they have a referral system so that if another blogger signs up to Blog Rush after clicking through to it from your widget you’ll get credits each time that the referral blog shows the widget. The referral system goes 10 tiers deep - so you can potentially get ALOT of credits.
That certainly doesn’t sound like a bad thing, right? Well, for the big guys it’s not. However, for anyone that signs up for BlogRush via an affiliate link, it could be a big problem. By signing up via an affiliate link, you’ll be promoting someone else’s content for free. Let’s say for example that I had signed up through John Chow’s affiliate link. Then I wrote a post recommending that everyone with a blog signed up for the program. Let’s say my post was incredibly successful and earned me 100 referrals. I’d then begin to earn credits on those referrals’ traffic and referrals, and my content would be displayed all over the place. However, I wouldn’t be the only one earning credits and having my content displayed, John’s content would be as well.
You’re Shooting Yourself in the Foot
Why is this a problem? To continue my explanation I’m going to use a math equation but just stick with me and it will simple, I promise. If I were John’s only referral, he’d be earning credits for the amount of traffic his blog generated (J), as well as my blog (M) and all my referrals’ sites (R) for a total of J+M+R. My total would obviously be M+R and last but not least my referrals total would simply be R. While other programs (such as Yuwie which I reviewed last week) run on this type of model, in BlogRush’s program, my content is competing with John’s for space. As you can see from the image to the left, there is limited space on each site. Since our blogs are in the same niche, my content would be displayed on the same sites as John’s. If he is continually reaping the benefits of my efforts as well as his own, his content will always be displayed more often than mine. No matter how many referrals I make or how much traffic my site drives, John would at a minimum, earn the same number of credits as me. When you consider the fact that the major bloggers will likely have hundreds of referrals, it’s easy to see who will benefit most from this program.
Bottom Line
Does this make BlogRush something to avoid? Not at all. However, I would urge you to NOT sign up for the service through the affiliate links of a site that is in your niche. You may also want to think twice before displaying the BlogRush widget on your site. After all, you might not want to promote sites you’re in direct competition with. However, if after considering these issues you decide to give BlogRush a shot (I did) and you author a blog about making money blogging or blogging tips, click over to BlogRush through this link (non aff) and sign up. Reap the benefits of your work and spend your time and effort promoting your own content, not mine. If your blog or website is about a different topic or niche, then by all means, I’d love it if you signed up through this link. If you do, as always, we’d love to hear about your experiences and impressions.
Update: I logged in to BlogRush this morning and was greeted by a message to BlogRush members from John Reese. It does address the “math” issue so I figured I should update this post to include this information:
In our video we mentioned that you earn a 1:1 ratio of syndication credits on your own traffic, and any direct referral’s traffic (such as “Bob” in the example video) and any direct referral’s referral traffic (yes, that sounds confusing!) such as “Jen” in our example. We also mentioned that you’d also earn credits based on activity through 10 generation levels. Here’s the breakdown of our formula:
Your Traffic = 1:1 1st Generation Of Referrals (Directly From You) = 1:1 2nd Generation Of Referrals (i.e. Jen in the video) = 1:1 3rd - 6th Generation Of Referrals = 1:4 7th - 10th Generation Of Referrals = 1:8
1:1 means you earn 1 syndication credit for every 1 impression of the widget by your own traffic or by any users located on the 1st (direct) or 2nd generations. 1:4 means you earn 1 syndication credit for every 4 impressions of the widget by any user located on the 3rd to 6th generations. 1:8 means you earn 1 syndication credit for every 8 impressions of the widget by any user located on the 7th to 10th generations.
When all of this math is added up, it leaves 1 headline space available out of every 10 that are served. This means that BlogRush uses 10% of the headline spots (5 headlines in each widget load) to monetize the service. We currently have plans to sell these extra credits to any user that would like to purchase additional credits — this is one of the ways we will pay for the service.
The decreasing returns certainly helps alleviate some of my concerns. I guess all that’s left now is to give it a spin and see what kind of results I get. I would still suggest avoiding signing up as a referral of someone in your niche as it just makes sense not to worry about splitting the returns on your work even at a 25% rate.
32 Responses
Naomi Dunford
September 17th, 2007 at 9:17 am
1Fantastic, fantastic, fantastic. Great review!
I honestly thought if I read one more review of BlogRush I would have no alternative but to shoot myself. Thankfully, I didn’t.
Don’t get me wrong, BlogRush sounds like a not-bad idea. I was just starting to wonder if I was the only person on earth who didn’t think it was the Second Coming. And while John Chow, Problogger, et al, are a very nice group of guys, I’d rather I made more profit from my own work than they did. Call me crazy.
Anyway, thanks for the review and I really enjoy reading your blog. Good luck in the remaining 280 days.
Edward Dowd
September 17th, 2007 at 9:18 am
2Why do you think all the large bloggers instantly posted about this service with an affiliate link? They knew they could get a few referral links, and get even more traffic. This system sounds like a “rich get richer” scheme. I don’t like (from my current perspective).
Ben Cook
September 17th, 2007 at 9:42 am
3@ Naomi, I’m glad you liked the review. Like you said it sounds like not a bad idea and in fact, I’ll probably put it in my sidebar to play around with and see how it does. And, as you mentioned, I don’t think any of the big bloggers I mentioned are doing anything shady, but I am of the opinion that if you don’t think before signing up you could be filling widgets with their content rather than yours. Like I said, if you’re not in the same industry or niche as the blogger you’re signing up under, then I don’t think it will be a big deal, but since most of the time people that read your blog are in a similar niche (which is why they read your blog), it could very well be a big issue for a lot of bloggers (especially the mindless hoards that follow John Chow’s every move and suggestion).
@ Edward, it definitely seems like a rich get richer situation and from the information we have available right now, I don’t think it’s going to be all that great either. Also, their website has disturbingly little information on it. For example, Yaro’s blog was the only place I’ve seen the fact that it’s a 10 tiered affiliate program. There are no details to be found. If for example you got 75% of your first tier, 50% of your second and so on then it might very well solve the problems I mentioned in this post. However, there isn’t any of that information on the site. When you’re going to do as large a marketing blitz as they’ve done, there’s no excuse not to have plenty of info available on your site.
Paul Bradish
September 17th, 2007 at 9:52 am
4I agree with your review. Like I mentioned on Graywolf - I’ve incredibly wary of these tier schemes but I’ve signed up for the service (against my gut). I’ll give it a month or two. If it doesn’t perform, I’ll simply drop it. I have no problem sending traffic out - but I’d like to see something worthwhile coming in for doing so :).
Naomi Dunford
September 17th, 2007 at 9:59 am
5You mean we’re not supposed to just blindly do whatever John Chow tells us to do?
Although I kind of like the idea of having my own colony of mindless hoards. Oh, did I say “mindless hoards”? I meant “fans”.
Jason Peck
September 17th, 2007 at 10:19 am
6Great review. I definitely was skeptical to claims that this would drastically increase my traffic. This may get people a few more views/clicks, just as posting on other blogs/forums, being on technorati and other social sites does. But I don’t see BlogRush doing anything magical, for most of us. But it can’t hurt to try.
Ben Cook
September 17th, 2007 at 10:25 am
7@ Jason, yeah, I don’t see it giving most people thousands of new visitors or anything, however, there might be one perk that I’ll be testing over the next few days hopefully. Could be pretty valuable if it works
Ben Cook
September 17th, 2007 at 10:53 am
8I’ve updated the post with some new information from the BlogRush website. It does ease some of my concerns but as I was looking around the site something occurred to me… why would anyone add a new blog under their current account, why wouldn’t you sign up as a referral that way you get credit for that traffic twice.
Really, if you have a bunch of blogs, you could stack them in reverse order of popularity, and leverage your most popular one to drive traffic to all the less popular ones and wracking up extra credits at every level!
BlogRush Did NOT Think About the Little Guys | Ian Fernando
September 17th, 2007 at 1:51 pm
9[…] Blogging Expirement has a great Math Equation: To continue my explanation I’m going to use a math equation but just stick with me and it will simple, I promise. If I were John’s only referral, he’d be earning credits for the amount of traffic his blog generated (J), as well as my blog (M) and all my referrals’ sites (R) for a total of J+M+R. My total would obviously be M+R and last but not least my referrals total would simply be R. While other programs (such as Yuwie which I reviewed last week) run on this type of model, in BlogRush’s program, my content is competing with John’s for space. […]
Matt Jones
September 17th, 2007 at 2:31 pm
10While your point is very interesting I’m not sure I agree with you. BlogRush is a traffic-sharing program and if you are not prepared to sign up through an affiliate link (effectively paying them for what they earned fair and square) do you deserve to make referrals of your own?
I’m not sure seeing other blogs in your niche as competitors is the way forward. Blogging and networking are about building mutually beneficial relationships. The ‘rich get richer’ model is what makes blogging so exiting.
It wouldn’t be very fair if a blogger who had either not tried or failed at building a popular blog suddenly had the ability to drive as much traffic as a top blogger.
My theory is that proportionally it is very fair. While John Chow may gain 1000s of extra visitors, percentage wise that would be an equal increase to a small blogger who gained a few extra unique per day and for the very ‘bottom bloggers’ the worst that could happen is that they would send away as much traffic as they receive.
Sorry if I came of as angry there lol ? I found your post very insightful.
Ben Cook
September 17th, 2007 at 2:41 pm
11@ Matt, generally I don’t think of other blogs as competition but when you’re talking about the limited space of the BlogRush widget that’s exactly what they are. Also, please read my post carefully, I recommend that anyone in my niche NOT sign up as a referral of mine.
The rich get richer model may be what makes blogging exciting but if everything worked as you suggest they should (in a proportional manner) then there’d never be anyone new breaking into the “rich” crowd and I would argue THAT’S what makes blogging so exciting. If it is always only the rich getting richer I doubt many people would bother.
You didn’t come off angry to me and as I’ve said several times in the past, I love good conversations with points being presented on both sides. I’ve found that it’s usually through this type of discussion that I learn the most so thanks very much for your contribution!
Why the Fuss about BlogRush? » techipedia | tamar weinberg’s blog of stuff
September 17th, 2007 at 6:46 pm
12[…] Cook wrote an incredible review about the shortcomings of BlogRush. His post is worth a read (there were referral concerns at first, as all URLs contain a […]
CFernandes
September 17th, 2007 at 10:25 pm
13I have also signed-up to try and gather some referrals, should this thing be around in a few months…
but I will also be doing a post in a couple of days explaining exactly why this will not be a success.
Jim Kukral
September 18th, 2007 at 10:02 am
14Exactly. Check out http://www.blogbucks.com it’s much better.
Adam Snider
September 18th, 2007 at 3:58 pm
15I don’t know how useful this will be. I’m already beginning to see loads of spam in people’s BlogRush widgets. I have no desire to add a widget to my blog that will publish links to splogs. I respect my readers more than that.
I suppose it could be used without the widget, but if everyone signed up and then didn’t use the widget on their blog, it would kind of defeat the purpose.
Ben Cook
September 18th, 2007 at 4:09 pm
16Adam, I completely agree. I’ve been keeping a close eye on the widget content and so far I’ve not been all that impressed. The stats are up finally and it looks like I’ve earned over 1000 credits from my traffic alone. I’ve also spent roughly 450 of those credits and received all of one click. That’s a pretty poor CTR especially considering 2 of the three posts I’ve written since posting the widget were BlogRush related (which would presumably catch people’s attention).
I’ll probably keep the widget up til the end of the week but I’m less than impressed.
isedb.com
September 18th, 2007 at 8:05 pm
17Don’t Rush to Sign Up for BlogRush by Blogging Experiment…
Should you avoid BlogRush? Few things to consider before jumping on the bandwagon….
SEO 2.0 | Blogrush Visitor Statistics: Who Gets Traffic, Who Does Not?
September 19th, 2007 at 2:40 am
18[…] extra value for your visitors”, but somewhere deep down in my head a voice said: “wait, don’t rush the Blogrush“. Last time I felt like this was with Agloco. It also sounded wonderful but also like a […]
Jayne
September 19th, 2007 at 2:45 am
19You’ve raised some good points. In truth, “pyramid plans” only benefit the people at the top.
They’ll be selling paid advertising on the widget? Doesn’t this mean that you’ll basically be showing ads for free then… why do this, when it will only compete with other ads on your site… ones that will BENEFIT you and you’re getting PAID to show.
Did I read this wrong? If not, there’s no way I’d sign up. Why put up free competition for my own Adsense ads?
BlogRush: Dead on Arrival by Blogging Experiment
September 19th, 2007 at 8:04 am
20[…] Posts BlogRush: Dead on ArrivalHow To Inflate Your BlogRush Credit CountDebate Points Not PeopleDon’t Rush to Sign Up for BlogRushFree Just For Signing UpWhat Hosting a Blog Contest Can Do for […]
Dewald
September 19th, 2007 at 4:30 pm
21Ben, I’ve raised a completely different red flag about BlogRush in a post on my blog.
In summary, with every impression of the widget, the BlogRush Javascript sends your blog page URL and the visitor Referrer URL back to the BlogRush server. That means BlogRush is receiving detail traffic information about your blog, i.e, how many visitors every page gets and where those visitors came from.
I have no idea why they’re doing this, because it can’t possible be required for the successful operation of BlogRush.
Ben Cook
September 19th, 2007 at 4:40 pm
22@ Dewald, I saw someone else bring that issue up as well (can’t quite remember where now) and John Reese actually addressed it and said that they plan on collecting the data to show overall stats at some point. You’d be surprised how many widgets and things like this actually do log the data. But yes, this does seem like something that BlogRush should address officially on their site.
Tim
September 20th, 2007 at 3:49 am
23Ben, GREAT ! The best review I read about BlogRush so far.
Keep up your good work !
–blog for dream–
Aurelius
September 22nd, 2007 at 6:36 pm
24As with Dewald above, my issue with it (and the reason I not signing up to it) is because it’s using Javascript, which as a wordpress.com user, I cannot post on my sidebars.
- Aurelius
» Pandia Weekend Wrap-up (Week 37-38/2007)
September 23rd, 2007 at 10:35 am
25[…] is just hype, some say. Ben Cook argues that signing up via an affiliate link, means that you will have to share your credits with […]
The Monetizer
September 24th, 2007 at 7:06 am
26Ben great points mentioned. And in your comment above, that is one strategy I have been employing; using a more frequently visited blog to try to bring visitors to a newer blog..So in that respect, BlogRush could be the golden ticket..
Roberto
September 25th, 2007 at 10:43 am
27lol. I had the same feeling. Initially I jumped at the idea but within a week I put the kibosh on the code and removed the widget. It just didn’t feel right after a day or two and I’m one of those guys that if something grinds my gears the wrong way then it must be wrong.
Great info though. You make a strong case against it and I’m sure that the information provided will help others along the way.
Mighty Blogger - Today’s Top Blog Posts on Blogging - Powered by SocialRank
October 1st, 2007 at 6:31 am
28[…] Don’t Rush to Sign Up for BlogRush by Blogging Experiment […]
Caroline’s Favourite Links & Blogs #2 | Caroline Middlebrook :: Livin' Online
October 13th, 2007 at 11:05 am
29[…] afraid to rock the boat. When BlogRush came out lots of people were hyping it up, but Ben told us not to rush to sign up, and furthermore he also posted some rather evil ways to inflate your Blogrush credits which I […]
redopinion.com » Blog Archive » How Not To Inspire Confidence In Your Customers
October 25th, 2007 at 6:16 pm
30[…] your articles displayed on other people’s websites. Despite almost unbelievable hype, many blogs have been skeptical about the company’s […]
David Bradley
January 9th, 2008 at 11:48 am
31I signed up, installed, monitored, and dumped, all within the space of two weeks. I’ve decided that ALL these kinds of apps and widgets are merely a distraction from my own content and where I really want to send my visitors after they’ve read my stuff. Avoid like the plague.
db
Simlock verwijderen
February 2nd, 2008 at 9:15 am
32I don’t rush on it. I don’t use it for my dutch blog, because the most of items you see on that Blogrush plugin is english-language and has to do with seo or marketing related topics which are not relevant for my visitors.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
to top of page...